Tags
Warning: This is a rant. Against Thanksgiving. If you love this holiday beyond reason, you may not want to read this entry.
I realize that Thanksgiving is considered one of those truly American, family-centered holidays. This is, no doubt due to the Pilgrim story with a dash of Norman Rockwell. And perhaps for some, it still fulfills that purpose. But for me — well, I can’t stand this holiday or at least what this holiday now seems to stand for. Here’s why.
First, I’d like to be able to say that my antipathy for Thanksgiving is because of a carefully reasoned political analysis of what whites have done to Native Americans — that the tale of the first Thanksgiving is just a myth to make many of us feel better or just ignore the betrayal and exploitation of indigenous people. But I’d be lying to claim that as the reason for my intense dislike of the day (though I do agree with this perspective and suggest this site as a place to start: http://www.uaine.org/).
In no particular order – here’s why this holiday bugs the sh*t out of me:
- The food is, for the most part, bland and beige. Has anyone really had a turkey that actually tastes yummy? The lengths that folks go to make that impossible goal happen are absurd — brining, seasoning, smoking, basting, etc., and if you still screw up you can call a 24 hour help hotline. Really — this is a good use of resources? The only color comes either from that nasty green bean dish with fake onions or cranberries in a can (though I’ll admit, I love the sound of that jellied cylinder coming out of the can).
- A second food point — I’m amazed at the number of food disasters I have witnessed as folks attempt to get a complete meal on the table. These include a thoroughly burnt turkey (totally black), a boiled in a bag turkey (a soggy mess — though moist), and a turkey that was put in the oven frozen (let’s call that the salmonella bird). Dishes are never ready all at the same time, so some get set aside and served luke warm to cold (when they should be hot), or you eat in shifts (sure, I’ll start with some brussel sprouts and wait 2 hours for the dinner rolls). And then, some guest has to bring his or her favorite side dish, which requires an elaborate preparation your kitchen, and doesn’t fit into the overall menu (and tastes like cardboard).
- Yet the food debacles notwithstanding, this holiday seems to stand for gluttony. Pants and belts undone, people groaning on the couch. Am I the only one who finds this repulsive? Do people really need to sample all the pies by creating one big pie with 8 different slices on a dinner plate?
- And the gendered roles come into full display. Men disappear into the TV room to watch football games and eat pre-dinner noshes. And as an aside – the football games feature either the Cowboys (which I hate) and/or the Lions (which til this year just sucked). But no matter, the guys are in their cave getting their feedbags on. On the other hand, the women are in the kitchen and dining rooms trying to make a ridiculous meal come to life. There’s tables to set, chafing dishes to dig out of the attic, potatoes to mash into oblivion. Once the meal is finally on the table, the head male gets to carve the turkey (and often acts as if he personally shot, cleaned and cooked it). Once the food has been annihilated, clean up beings. And guess who gets to do that? Guess who heads back to the cave until the multi-flavor pie plates get created? This makes me crazy (and I don’t want to hear about those men who are modern enough to help in the kitchen — this is my rant).
- The stress is often off the charts. Food prep stress. People getting along stress. Travel stress. ”This needs to be perfect” uber-stress. Is it worth it to drive oneself so crazy?
- I also have some bad personal associations with Thanksgiving. My marriage imploded over Thanksgiving. The last time I saw my maternal grandfather was over Thanksgiving. Some of the worst fights I had with my dad was over Thanksgiving. Why didn’t Arbor Day get wrecked instead?
- Crass commercialism has completely taken over. Supposedly, this is the start of the Christmas shopping season, though in actuality, that started around Labor Day. I hate this — I really really hate this. I hate all the ads. I hate the crazy Friday when everyone has to go to the malls. I hate that we can’t slow down and just focus on one holiday at a time. If I could change one thing, this would be it. Absolutely no Christmas anything until after Thanksgiving.
Now, in case anyone is worried, I have had some good Thanksgivings, and wouldn’t necessarily turn down an invitation in the future (though these probably won’t be forthcoming any time soon). But for the most part, it is just too stressful, awkward and unfulfilling. Yes, I know that there are many folks who love the holiday and all it means (and good for them). But I’m not one of them.
What I’ve realized over the years, is that it is essential that I stay in touch with what works, and what doesn’t, for me. For the most part, Thanksgiving doesn’t work. Being grateful for all that I have is important and I try to do that, at least in some small way, each day.
It is also why the “holiday” that I truly celebrate (complete with family, friends, and lots of food) is “Gotcha Day.” On March 14th, I mark the day that the adoption of my daughter became official. It is the day we honor becoming a family, and I have never been more thankful for anything or anyone in my life.
